Shrimpsvoices

Under Judas we played 40 games including Cup games. Won 10 Lost 20 Drew 10

Under DA we've played 12 games Won 3 Lost 6 Drew 3

Their respective records are not that dissimilar BUT under DA I feel we have more of a chance of EFL1 next season than had Judas still been here.

redrobo wrote:Under Judas we played 40 games including Cup games. Won 10 Lost 20 Drew 10

Under DA we've played 12 games Won 3 Lost 6 Drew 3

Their respective records are not that dissimilar BUT under DA I feel we have more of a chance of EFL1 next season than had Judas still been here.

2 of Judas's wins were against Buxton and Newport as well.

We would have been below Wimbledon now with Judas in charge. Interesting to see the St Mirren fans comments on his 1 win in 10 matches.

Gone_Shrimping wrote:

redrobo wrote:Under Judas we played 40 games including Cup games. Won 10 Lost 20 Drew 10

Under DA we've played 12 games Won 3 Lost 6 Drew 3

Their respective records are not that dissimilar BUT under DA I feel we have more of a chance of EFL1 next season than had Judas still been here.

2 of Judas's wins were against Buxton and Newport as well.

We would have been below Wimbledon now with Judas in charge. Interesting to see the St Mirren fans comments on his 1 win in 10 matches.

True, but for balance, two of his defeats were PNE & Spurs.

Keith wrote:

Gone_Shrimping wrote:

redrobo wrote:Under Judas we played 40 games including Cup games. Won 10 Lost 20 Drew 10

Under DA we've played 12 games Won 3 Lost 6 Drew 3

Their respective records are not that dissimilar BUT under DA I feel we have more of a chance of EFL1 next season than had Judas still been here.

2 of Judas's wins were against Buxton and Newport as well.

We would have been below Wimbledon now with Judas in charge. Interesting to see the St Mirren fans comments on his 1 win in 10 matches.

True, but for balance, two of his defeats were PNE & Spurs.

I think for the Tottenham game D O was in charge with Judas testing positive , either way that defeat wasn't a shocker.

I still can't believe we lost at home to Crewe and Wimbledon who are both poor teams

redrobo wrote:Under Judas we played 40 games including Cup games. Won 10 Lost 20 Drew 10

Under DA we've played 12 games Won 3 Lost 6 Drew 3

Their respective records are not that dissimilar BUT under DA I feel we have more of a chance of EFL1 next season than had Judas still been here.

Two Robbos wins are against Newport and Buxton then?!?

Disregarding that, the records are also not like for like in terms of strength of opponent. Robinson managed all of the games against the sides below us in the table at the moment - his record is skewed by this. I actually think one of the reasons behind his departure was when he looked at our run-in he didn't fancy his chances of steering us clear of safety - and because of this didn't want relegation on his CV. He probably did us a favour, the shithouse coward.

Robbo record vs bottom 5:
P10 W3 D3 L4

Wimbledon and Gills both took 4 points off us this season - which changes the complexion of the table completely.

You can also add another point onto Robbos record due to the incredibly poor GD we have, which could still count against us on Saturday. Going to places like Sunderland playing 4-3-3 didn't help with that.

RedRedWine wrote:

redrobo wrote:Under Judas we played 40 games including Cup games. Won 10 Lost 20 Drew 10

Under DA we've played 12 games Won 3 Lost 6 Drew 3

Their respective records are not that dissimilar BUT under DA I feel we have more of a chance of EFL1 next season than had Judas still been here.

Two Robbos wins are against Newport and Buxton then?!?

Disregarding that, the records are also not like for like in terms of strength of opponent. Robinson managed all of the games against the sides below us in the table at the moment - his record is skewed by this. I actually think one of the reasons behind his departure was when he looked at our run-in he didn't fancy his chances of steering us clear of safety - and because of this didn't want relegation on his CV. He probably did us a favour, the shithouse coward.

Robbo record vs bottom 5:
P10 W3 D3 L4

Wimbledon and Gills both took 4 points off us this season - which changes the complexion of the table completely.

You can also add another point onto Robbos record due to the incredibly poor GD we have, which could still count against us on Saturday. Going to places like Sunderland playing 4-3-3 didn't help with that.

We also lost at home to Crewe under Judas. Probably our worst result of the season bearing in mind how poor Crewe are.

RedRedWine wrote:
I actually think one of the reasons behind his departure was when he looked at our run-in he didn't fancy his chances of steering us clear of safety - and because of this didn't want relegation on his CV. He probably did us a favour, the shithouse coward.

A few said this at the time and I wasn't so sure but it does look that way now. I have been keeping an eye on St Mirren results and their fans reaction to him and the general consensus from a few seems to be that it's not his team, they're probably safe from relegation this season and the real work will start in the summer when he can bring players he wants in. If that was always the plan then why couldn't he see out the season with us first?

I agree that he's done us a favour though, no way do we get the wins we have with him still in charge. I think we'd have been relegated a few weeks ago under Judas.

Dr Mirren were 4th or 5 th in the league there was nothing wrong with the team he inherited so not sure why he needs a rebuild.

P/T Indie wrote:Dr Mirren were 4th or 5 th in the league there was nothing wrong with the team he inherited so not sure why he needs a rebuild.

When he was appointed at st missery he was given the remit to get them into the top 6 and possibly Europe, 1 win in 10 games later they are 10th out of 12th. ONE win since he took charge! It's not going as well as they planned eh? At one stage after he left us he was in the running to relegate 2 sides in 2 different countries in the same season!!